Your Spooky Neighbors

Hosted ByGracey Mussina and Stephanie Hofstra

(Explicit) Join two neighbors from Grand Rapids, Michigan in a podcast both wholesome and haunting. Your Spooky Neighbors explores all the dark corners from our world and beyond-- from true crime, the paranormal, urban legends, and all things generally creepy and strange.

Episode 4: Michigan Craigslist Killer

Spread the love

Brady Oestrike was your typical nerd who was into medieval weapons, LARPing, cosplay, Dungeons & Dragons, BDSM… and apparently carrying women he met on Craigslist around in suitcases?

Gracey and Stephanie unpack a lot of heavy details in the tragic murder of pregnant 18 year old Brooke Slocum and her boyfriend Charles Oppenneer. We’re letting you know now that this case is a car crash full of emotions.


Have a personal true crime story or paranormal encounter you’d like to share with us? We’d love to hear from you! Send us an email over at

For updates and extra content, follow Your Spooky Neighbors on social media: