In 1961, along New Hampshire’s winding US route 3, Betty and Barney Hill lost time, innocence, and nearly their minds after encountering a UFO and being abducted by “grey” nonhuman beings. The Hills were examined, probed, and then sent on their way, only to be haunted by vivid dreams and unplaced memories. After reporting their experience to the U.S. Air Force, seeing a psychiatrist, and undergoing hypnosis, their experiences came to light only to be publicized and refuted. We will recount their story, discuss the aftermath, and hopefully open your mind to new possibilities.