After two years of doing the podcast, Sammy finally decides to tackle the conspiracy of the reptilian elite. Then, Tessa takes us back to the spooky vibes from early seasons by talking about Indrid Cold or the Smiling Man.

After almost two years, Sammy finally gets to talk about the Mattress Firm conspiracy theory, and then Tessa talks about the Missouri local legend, Momo the Monster.

For our second April Fool’s Day we decided to not make up a conspiracy theory and cryptid because we figured you all would be expecting that. So, instead, Sammy tells us about the conspiracy that Elvis Presley faked his own death and is still alive. Then, Tessa talks about the Maryland cryptid, and other amalgamation…

Tessa has chosen a massive creepy crawler known as the J’ba FoFi as a way to tap into Sammy’s massive arachnophobia, and then, to lighten the mood, Sammy finally talks about the Flat Earth conspiracy!

Coming back at you for episode 38, Tessa’s here to talk to you about the infamous Hopkinsville Goblin and the creepy story surrounding it, and then Sammy takes us on another trek through the history books to teach us about the Lost Colony of Roanoke.

Sammy’s back at it again this week with another conspiracy steeped in history, the Knights Templar. And then Tessa delves into the cryptid ghost story known as La Llorona!

This week Sammy teaches us the history and theories behind the infamous Project MKUltra, and Tessa tells us about the urban legend cryptid known as the Pope Lick Monster.

Welcome to Season 4! We’re taking the premise of our swapisodes, where Sammy and Tessa swap topics, and applying it to the entire season, that we’re calling a swapiseason. So, Tessa goes first for the New Year and talks about the bizarre cryptid known as the Dingonek, and Sammy finally gets to talk about the…

Going a little outside the norm for the holidays this year, Tessa talks about the controversial Dutch holiday tradition of Zwarte Piet (Black Pete), and Sammy also covers the Norweigan character of Krampus.

We get lost at sea this week as Tessa sails us through the Bermuda Triangle and somehow wind up on the shores of Puerto Rico so Sammy can lead us on a safari to track down the elusive Chupacabra.